What Actually Happens in Your Body
Fasting is often talked about as an on/off switch — fasted or not fasted.
In reality, it’s more like a dimmer switch.
Let’s walk through what your body is doing while fasting, and then what changes the moment you introduce a piccolo.
The Fasted State: What’s Going On?
When you’ve been fasting for several hours (say 12–24 hours), your body shifts into a very specific metabolic mode:
1. Insulin is low
- Blood glucose is stable or slightly low
- Insulin stays suppressed
- This allows fat cells to release fatty acids
2. You’re running on fat + ketones
- Liver releases fatty acids and ketones
- Muscles and brain start using these for fuel
- Fat oxidation is high
3. Growth hormone rises
- Helps preserve muscle
- Supports fat mobilisation
4. Autophagy ramps up (especially after ~18–24h)
- Cells recycle damaged components
- This is one of the “longevity” benefits people chase
Black coffee fits neatly into this state — it has no nutrients that meaningfully interrupt these processes.
Then You Have a Piccolo
A piccolo looks innocent: a shot of espresso with a small amount of milk.
But milk is biologically loud.
Let’s break it down.
What’s in the milk?
Even 20–30 ml of milk contains:
- Lactose (milk sugar → glucose + galactose)
- Milk proteins (especially whey)
- A small amount of fat
Calories are low — but signalling matters more than calories.
The Insulin Response: Yes, It Happens
The moment milk hits your gut:
1. Lactose raises blood glucose (slightly)
- Not a big spike
- But enough for the pancreas to notice
2. Whey protein strongly stimulates insulin
This is the key point many people miss:
Milk proteins are disproportionately insulinogenic
Even without much glucose, whey:
- Triggers insulin release
- Signals “nutrients are coming in”
3. Insulin rises — briefly
- Fat release from adipose tissue slows
- Ketone production dips
- Autophagy pauses
This is not a disaster — but it is a metabolic interruption.
What Does Insulin Actually “Do” Here?
Think of insulin as a traffic controller:
- During fasting:
👉 “We’re in scarcity mode — burn fat, recycle cells” - After the piccolo:
👉 “Pause scarcity — nutrients detected”
So yes:
- Fat burning slows
- Autophagy pauses
- The fast is technically broken
But context matters.
How Big Is the Impact, Really?
Timeline:
- Insulin rises for 30–90 minutes
- Then returns to baseline
- Fat oxidation resumes
You don’t “lose” your fasted adaptations — you briefly interrupt them.
This is why fasting isn’t binary.
The Stress Trade-Off (Important)
For many people, especially active ones:
- Black coffee → cortisol spike, jitters, nausea
- Piccolo → calmer nervous system, better compliance
Chronically elevated cortisol can:
- Raise blood glucose
- Increase insulin anyway
- Undermine fat loss goals
So paradoxically, forcing black coffee can sometimes be worse.
So Is a Piccolo “Bad” While Fasting?
If your goal is:
Fat loss, metabolic health, consistency
👉 The piccolo is fine
If your goal is:
Maximising autophagy, strict fasting protocols
👉 Skip the milk
If your goal is:
Getting through the day without feeling awful
👉 Piccolo beats quitting the fast altogether
The Honest Take
A piccolo:
- Does spike insulin
- Does pause the fast
- Does not undo the benefits of fasting
- May improve adherence and stress levels
Fasting works best when it’s sustainable, not dogmatic.
Leave a Reply